Kheper Home | Ken Wilber Home | Integral Movement | Integral Paradigm | Topics Index | Esotericism | News and Events | Khepershop | Search

Ken Wilber's Philosophy, and some critical appraisals


Ken Wilber

Gurus/Spiritual Masters
Ken Wilber
current suggested assesment

back to alphabetical listing
Tradition Transpersonal Psychology, but since established his own tradition (Wilberian Integral)
Guru Adi Da
Category Dogmatist/Nondual
Psychology Generous Narcissist/Shadow Projection
Inspiration Intermediate zone?
Important Students Allan Combs, Stuart Davis, Mark Edwards, Sean Hargens, Brad Reynolds, Frank Visser was ad hominem attacked by Wilber because he hosts a peer-review criticism website, and is now blog an important critic.
Criticism See Critics section, also external link A Spectrum of Critics.
Abuses Sexual - Mild
Financial - Mild (blogosphere I-I / IU as merchandising)
Emotional - Mild
Thought - High (Suppression of discusssion, 3 Cards Trick)
Antagonism - Moderate
Control info - Mild (external link Integral Institute lack of openness)
External - None
Cultism - Moderate - Organisation, update, external link My essay part 2d, blogosphereNeuro-Linguistic manipulation)
Assesment Highly charismatic New Age theorist who seems to get his amazing enthusiasm from the intermediate zone; Generous to those who praise him, antagonistic to those who criticise him


Ken Wilber - an overview of sorts (including material compiled from elsewhere). Also see My take on Ken Wilber for a more opinionated look.


Ken Wilber's Five Stages:

Phase 1 - The "Romantic" Period

Phase 2 - The Pre-Trans Cycle

The Atman Fiasco - a detailed critique of the Atman Project, by Arvan Harvat

Phase 3 - Multiple Development - Holographic Mind

Phase 4 - All Quadrants All Levels

A Glance at Ken Wilber's "A Brief History of Everything" - review by Arvan Harvat

A Critique of Ken Wilber's "AQAL" Philosophy - Phases 4 and 5

Historical Parallels - Pico della Mirandola, and H.P. Blavatsky - especially Phases 4 and 5

Phase 5: Post-Metaphysical

Ken Wilber's Methodology

Ken Wilber, like myself, is a Hedgehog who is trying to formulate a Theory of Everything. Unfortunately, Wilber attacks rather than incorporates the evidence of physical biological evolution, so his evolutionary paradigm cannot be as complete or as reliable as those, like say Erich Jantsch, who are not fazed by the implications of Darwinism.


Miscellaneous Critiques:

Ken Wilber's "Two Truths" Monism

Ken Wilber's interpretation of Sri Aurobindo

Ken Wilber's anti-darwinism

Ken Wilber's Methodology - a critique

The Cult of Ken Wilber by Michel Bauwens

Meeting Wilber by anon.

Towards a Larger Definition of the Integral - An Aurobindonian vision and a critique of the Wilberian paradigm my essay in four parts - external link part 1, part 2, part 3, part 4, on Integral World

Integral Esotericism my essay in eight parts - external link part 1, part 2, part 3, part 4, part 5, part 6, part 7, and part 8, on Integral World

See also the thoughtful reply (from a quasi-wilberian? perspective) to part 1 of the above essay at Indistinct Union (Chris Dierkes); blogosphere esoteric integralism pt1, esoteric integralism pt2

Redefining the Integral short essay, at blogosphere Integral Praxis


Recent meltdowns...

Wilber's rant, and responses

The Cult of Ken Wilber revisited by Michel Bauwens

blog On Wilber's latest meltdown (Open Integral)


Kheper index page
Topics index page
Integral Movement main page
Integral Paradigm main page

Kheper Home | Ken Wilber Home | Integral Movement | Integral Paradigm | Topics Index | Esotericism | News and Events | Khepershop | Search


images not loading? | error messages? | broken links? | suggestions? | criticism?
contact me

page by M.Alan Kazlev
page uploaded 13 December 1999, last modified 8 September 2007